Elijah is in the
1880 Census
he buried at
Frankindale Cemetery
There is quite a lot of detail on his family in
J. M. Pelton, . Genealogy of the Pelton family in America : being a record of the descendants of John Pelton who settled in Boston, Mass., about 1630-1632, and died in Dorchester, Mass., January 23rd, 1681. Albany, N.Y.: Joel Munsell's Sons, 1892. Available at Ancestry.com.
Also available here J M Pelton. at OpenLibrary.org.
He is # 594. Elijah Pelton fifth son of Elijah R., son of John, son of Samuel, Benjamin, Samuel, John. on page 597 of the Pelton book.
Benjamin is Benjamin Pelton on Wikitree. Benjamin's ancestors are entered but his descendants have not been.