Hi Joan, thanks for the feedback. But there seems to be quite a few generalizations and misunderstandings I would like to respond to:
I do not think I would have enjoyed it so much if I had been a new member, keen to get my family onto WikiTree.
As a long-time user myself, I can definitely see how it might not seem useful to new members who were itching to get started adding family - but we have seen quite the opposite response so far. We have had feedback from some very new members who were struggling with the site, and after taking the course were thankful for the Academy and the [currently limited] information it provided. I have received no less than 20 messages (all from members who were new to the site) thanking us for the NMHT course and begging for more content.
Also, it will not be a good way of learning for everyone, one size does not fit all and people learn in different ways. I can see that the academy might be useful for short courses of a specific subject and material could be added that will support the work of trails. I seems to me that its a bit like having an help page that works in a different way.
This is 100% true, and one of the items that the Academy is hoping to enhance on WikiTree - different and connected ways of learning. I hope you will not take this first course as the only way members can learn on/through the Academy - it is very far from using all of the features available.
As Doug mentioned, the underlying software we are using is currently in use in over 164,000+ organizations across the world, with more than 352 million users across both academic and enterprise level usage.1
The software was designed to support both teaching and learning through a host of collaborative course tools like forums, wikis, glossaries, database activities, and much more. It supports progress tracking, reporting, has multilingual capabilities, offers a range of embedded content (e.g., videos, audio, slides, or H5P), and even has options for real-time sharing of audio, video, slides, whiteboard, chat and screen. It even support open learning standards like SCORM content.
Looking at the stats that Steve has provided, 68 people completing the New Member How to Course is a drop in the ocean, when you consider how many people are on WikiTree, and many of them could be people like me, who are just looking, to see what it is about. A lot of work still needs to be done, just to make people aware that the academy is here, let alone enabling new members to find it.
A very small drop in the bucket indeed - but also keep in mind that there has not been a whole lot of advertisement of the Academy just yet. This is especially true for new members. But that will change...
We are looking at ways to integrate this into the new member onboarding process as an option to learn more about the site rather than reading and navigating through pages and hoping they find the information they need. Ways to integrate existing information into new formats that help members learn about not just the site, but genealogy in general - in ways that they can understand.
Will every member enjoy the Academy? Absolutely not! But if we can help even a fraction of the new and existing membership, then the Academy is serving its purpose.
In my opinion the academy will never replace trails. It lacks the personal touch of trails. Our trails do fantastic work and our awesome Trail Guides are invaluable to WikiTree, giving up their time to make friends with new members and help them to learn about WikiTree and intergrate them into our community.
This is something that has always baffled me - the notion (accusations) that the Academy was replacing anything. It has only been proposed as a compliment to WikiTree; available for those who want to make use of it (as Teachers or Students). It is not meant to replace help pages, informational space pages created by members, or the work being done through trails, or even replacing Trail Guides for that matter - and this has never been suggested - but often repeated or implied.
Perhaps communications have not been clear in those regards? In that case - I have always had an open door policy... Anyone can contact me at any time for clarification, to ask questions, or even just to share thoughts.
I should decalre that I am an England Project Leader and so have a big interest in ensuring that the England Project Orphan Trail continues to be a success. I rather see the academby as a potential servant of our trail, doing some of the repetitive jobs to save work for our Trailblazers. Then our Trailblazers will be able to spend more time doing what they do best, being a friend, and introducing people into a community full of love, friendship and fun.
The Academy wants to be a servant to your trail! That is exactly what it is built for. It is an offering to help the WikiTree community (as well as trails and Guides) to achieve their goals by providing a platform what they can share their knowledge, skills, and passion with a broader community in different formats by using blended learning techniques that take the administrative functions out of the equation and allow us to focus more on helping others.
1 https://stats.moodle.org/