Parmelee-499 Conflated?

Question

I've just entered a comment on Parmaeee-499's profile pointing out what appear to be huge inconsistencies between that profile and the profile of her first spouse, Isaac Hill. Specifically, he's reported to have had 15 children with his only spouse, Susannah Parmelee. She's reported to have married her second spouse 5 years after her marriage to Isaac Hill. Fifteen children in five years? Really?

See the profiles for more information.

Hill-44086

Parmelee-499

Comments

Isaac's bio says he was married to Ann Parmelee, so clearly a bad attachment. Anne and Susanna are not interchangeable names.

I'd add a message on Isaac's profile and the children Ahira and Daniel. And then do a disconnect. Ahira is a child of Isaac and Anna b. in Guilford according to the Barbour Collection of CT Vital Records. The Daniel b. 1734 is not listed in Barbour, which doesn't mean he isn't a child of Isaac but wasn't recorded in Guilford

Answer 1

This family definitely needs to be sorted out.  That's why I've been hesitant to complete the profiles.