Help with Error Questions

Question

good evening all

I have several  ?.  as i work on my error  report,  , when ifirst joined over a month ago,  i had added  family  memebers and when i added a few more, they were pree  1500,  well  dummy me, could ot edit themwell i have learned so much since then.   I have  3  different profiles,  that  need to be  edited that are pree   1500, some of the hters have  done the profile  and  sources, and it seems they have missed  this  up.   There are others besides me listed as to fix this profile, and i have asked some of them to help me as i can not do it.   Boy i can not  believe   the way  soem of them acted, like  some did not know what i was talking about, as i sent    website,  profile  number everything i could,  some said they would look, and no one ever got back to me.  is there anyone out there,  that  can  help me  get these profiles fixed. These items tjat meed foxomg  are  sp ,ompr. o wosj o cpi;d dp ot. bit mpt mp badge   for pre 1500
1.
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Bohun-255 Wikidata - Different birth dateDetails  1
Bohun-2 , birthdate  from profile, and  bio are  worng.

2.  305 Mother too young or not born , https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Bohun-2, Bohun-2
     305 Mother too young or not born,  https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Courtenay-99, Courtenay-99
3.  558 Wikidata - Different death date     Bohun-2, https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Bohun-2

 

thank you for any help out there

debbie mcdonald

Comments

Those links you have provided lead to "Page does not exist"

---

A while ago, I sent you a message that on your own profile you have Schmitt as other last name while that is also listed as your LNAB, so it displays twice.  What's up with that one?

---

Bohun-255 doesn't exist. The others have a comma included in the URL, which breaks it.

Answer 1

Ok, it does not look like you are the profile manager on these profiles, so, I would just post in the comments field on the profiles about the errors on these profiles.

Comments

I agree with this suggestion, but would just add that with pre-1500 profiles in at least 95% of cases its Wikidata that has the error not Wikitree.

Answer 2

The birth date of https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Bohun-2  was a error, was right in text. Have corrected

The death date was right and didn't seem to differ from wiki data so  marked false error. ( I seem to find this happens quite often, it is perplexing)*

The birth date of son Thomas was incorrect, have corrected and sourced as on parents profile from Richardson.

* can someone explain what ''statement with mainsnak date marked as Julian that is more precise than 1 year''actually means. 

As far as I'm concerned the dates weren't in the Jan to Lady day period and were as written at the time

Comments

mainsnak = mistake?

---

@Helen looks like you have found Wikidata records that Wikidata has marked as potential wrong date because use of wrong calendar see Phabricator ticket T105100 (Phabricator is Wikidata tracking system)

from  T105100 "We need to run a bot that adds a qualifier to all statements with a potentially wrong date. The qualifier should be something like "instance of: Wikidata date needing calendar model check".

See also G2G discussion

The problem WikiTree has when comparing with Wikidata is that WikiTree has today no calendar at all set... which makes the equation difficult to solve...