The birth information for John Dibble Jr. WAS incorrect (15 December 1702). The John Dibble born on that date was son of Josiah and Hannah (not John and Mary). John Dibble Jr. possibly born in Massachusetts (like his older sister Mary). I today finally identified his wife as Mary Benedict, and they were married in Connecticut. UPDATE: Birth information has now been corrected. However, the only source is that given in my answer below (and not likely a birth record in New York can be found).