Unfortunately, in the Goodman line, the names Benjamin, William, Samuel, Joseph, Rowland, and perhaps others, occur with some regularity with every generation. I've forgotten how many Benjamins we have, but we also have one Benjamin Lewis and one Benjamin Louis that I recall.
I will also mention that much of the data on the Goodman History and Genealogy website has long since been discrediited. I do believe he has some of the family wills though and they are accurate.
As to the individual family trees on Ancestry, they will have to be researched, with their sources, one at a time. I'm certainly willing to be persuaded that Benjamin married Joanna Webster and they had children and then they divorced or she died. However, it will take more than a discustion on Ancestry. It will take Vestry Books, census records, marriage records, etc.
My brother went to England twice and found no record of any wife other than Lucie. He also hired an English firm to research the issue further. They only found one wife. Benjamin's will only refers to one wife, Lucie. In that will he names each of his children. Those children are listed on the profile for Goodman-2071.
I am not familiar with the Annals of Philadelphia. . .., so I cannot say if there is any factual linkage between Goodman-2071 and the story about the servant.
Again I am not famliar with Lost in the Woods. Is it a book? If so I will try to locate a copy. So I cannnot comment on the factualness of the theories posed there.
In any event there is enough here to keep us all digging for some time.