Is there any evidence that Thomas Gardner-159 had a daughter Susannah, born 1638 in Salem, Massachusetts

Question

I'm starting to work on cleaning up the family of Thomas Gardner-159, who immigrated to Cape Ann in 1624, then moved to Salem in 1626. Anderson's article in the Great Migration Begins, pages 731-737, lists 9 children of Thomas's first marriage to 'Unknown'. Susannah, b. 1638 is not listed there. Does anyone have any evidence she was the daughter of Thomas Gardner-159? Does she belong to someone else, or should her profile be merged into the profile of one of her sisters?

Comments

Likewise, one of the sources I look at (http://ma-vitalrecords.org/MA/Essex/Salem/aBirthsG.shtml) doesn't list a Susannah Gardner ... not that this site is overly complete.

---

I see I asked this question (on the profile) back in 2013 and no one answered. I'd say detach her, but include a link to her in the narrative. I take that back. It looks like she died within a year. Is that possibly why she wasn't listed by Anderson? Does Salem have VRs for that time period? If she's not there, I'd be tempted to merge her away.

---

The Salem records Bob indicated don't show any Susannah Gardner born to anyone in that time frame. And a search of American Ancestors database didn't turn up a Susannah Gardner born in Salem at that time. I'll write directly to the PM for her profile to ask if he objects.

Answer 1

Not that I'm aware of.  Unless someone comes up with a valid source in the next few days, I'd merge her away...

Comments

I'll give the PM another couple of days to respond. Thanks for your response!