Who is the wife of Marvel Derrick-270, Taylor-24399 or Taylor-57327.

Question

Julia Ann Taylor-24399.  In 1850 census she is in household of Penalton Taylor-24385, Living in Granger Co., Granger, Tennessee.  Born in Tennessee, age 13.

Julia Ann Taylor-57327.  In 1850 census she is in household of John Taylor-57328, living in Alamance Co., Alamance, North Carolina.  Born in North Carolina, age 16.  

In 1860 census the 2 Julia Ann Taylors are not listed with their parents.  A Julia Ann is listed in household of Marvel Derrick.   Find a Grave #71029997 (grave of Julia Ann Taylor, wife of Marvel Derrick) reads: Born 05 Sept 1834, Died 01 April 1906.  You will see that someone thinks she may have died in 1904.  It was Julia Ann Wininger Derrick, #71063741 that died in 1904.  

Note that Taylor-24399 and Taylor-57327 have the same birth and death dates and North Carolina as birth location on their profile page.    The 1850 census shows which is correct.

Answer 1

Fred, I’ve added a tag for the Arborists Project. They specialize in untangling intertwined branches of the tree.

Answer 2

I am requesting that G2G check the information I have provided and determine which Julie Taylor married Marvel Derrick.  Ii is my understanding that this is one of the many things G2G does.  Thank You.