Would an Arborist merge the following 2 Andrew Smith profiles?

Question

Smith-146122 and Smith-2869 are similar, but both might have information from fraudulent genealogies.  I want to make sure the merge, if any, is done correctly.

Answer 1

I added some spacing 'for readability' into the profiles of Andrew Smith-146122 and Olive 'Pitt', who is mother of his son, Thomas.  From a somewhat quick review, based on the biographies in Andrew and Olive's profiles, they do look like a duplicated family since all of the children that are linked in Smith-2689 are mentioned in the other profiles.

 I have proposed a merge for son and his mother to the related people in Smith-2689 family.