Among the sons of my 3GGF John Frederick Leyde (1773-1843) were my 2GGF Frederick Leyde (1802-1890) and his brother John George Leyde, Sr. (1798-1875). Each named a son "Frederick Alexander Leyde" - Frederick’s son my GGU Frederick Alexander Leyde (1832-1907) and John George’s son my 1C3R Frederick Alexander Leyde (1830-1904). Both were born in Pennsylvania and later lived in Minnesota. Their records seemed hopelessly intermingled on both Ancestry and FamilySearch. Technology helped me separate them, although their profiles are still a work in progress.
John Frederick Leyde, like his Revolutionary War veteran father John Lyde (1732-1810) before him, was a farmer in Somerset Township, Washington County, Pennsylvania. Both were involved in the Whiskey Rebellion (Insurrection) of 1791-1794. After his father died, the family moved to Ohio as the U.S. frontier expanded westward.
John Frederick’s sons took different paths. John George ran a sawmill in Lawrence County, PA, in 1850 and was a stone mason there in 1860. That family branch moved to Minnesota before the Civil War.
16-year-old Frederick, with 3 months of schooling, kept books in a store and post office where he later clerked and expanded into a mercantile business. He then set up a wholesale provision and supply business in Pittsburgh. Around 1852, 50-year-old Frederick purchased farmland and moved the family to Minnesota.
Why John George and Frederick both named sons born a year or so apart Frederick Alexander Leyde isn’t known, but it has caused confusion to family genealogists for a long time, including during a vast Leyde/Leyda family reunion in 1933 that undertook to build a thorough family tree. I’ve certainly struggled with it 90 years later, but technology provided an answer, and not modern IT but technology of the day.
John George Leyde as a sawyer and stone mason was technically oriented. So it seems logical that his son Frederick Alexander Leyde would also be technically minded working in his father’s business. At 24, he moved to St Paul, Minnesota in 1855, where he was a machinist and engineer. Representing the firm of Wood, Tabor & Morse (South Otselic, New York), he introduced the first steam thresher into Minnesota. It was designed to burn either wood, coal, or straw. He died on 10 Feb 1904 in Saint Paul, Ramsey, Minnesota.
Frederick Leyde’s son grew up around the provisioning business and worked on the family farm. Yesterday I found a record that Frederick A. Leyde applied for a military 160-acre land warrant under the Scrip Warrant Act of 1855 (10 Stat. 701) on 10 April 1860 in Faribault, Minnesota, after service on the Ship Constitution ("Old Ironsides") of the United States Navy. So he became a farmer. Little else is known of him, but the farm in Faribault offers a clue for further research.
While I’m on it, a further source of confusion surrounding Frederick A. Leyde regards a “dark family secret”, a scandal so great that the Leyde/Leyda conclave of 1933 apparently tried to cover it up. Enter my 2GGF Frederick Leyde’s daughter Harriett Williams “Hattie” Leyde Scholer Leyde. After a very tough life that included the death of three of her children in Deadwood, Dakota Territory during the gold rush kicked off by General G.A. Custer of the 7th Cavalry's 1874 Black Hills expedition that found gold and stirred up the Sioux leading to the Little Big Horn Battle in June 1876, widowed Hattie married widower Frederick Alexander Leyde. Because some at the 1933 conclave thought that she married her brother they removed her from the list of her parents’ children. In fact, 46-year-old Hattie married her 57-year-old first cousin Frederick Alexander Leyde on 25 Oct 1887 in Saint Paul, Minnesota, which others found equally scandalous. They solved this conundrum by showing a "Harriett Williams Scholar" (her earlier married name) as married to my 1C3R Frederick Alexander Leyde, thus avoiding the odor of impropriety.
One last thing. My 1C3R Frederick Alexander Leyde, engineer, seems to have been a very decent person. He had been in the relief force at the Battle of Birch Coulee when Sioux warriors of Gray Bird (Zitkahtahhota), Mankato, and Big Eagle (Wamditanka) ambushed a detail of Minnesota Militia sent to bury dozens of victims of the New Ulm Massacre and besieged them for 30 hours in the deadliest battle of the Dakota War of 1862. 35-year-old Frederick married Mary Jane Esterling Colledge, the young widow of Sergeant John Colledge who was killed during the Battle of Birch Coulee, and raised her children as his own.