Squinting, staring, guessing, and - not to forget - collaboration might get us there eventually.
"23 Maria ...o...: francis
par: christ: bernard ... antonel
henseler pat: lud... Wesse...d...
nata h..."
The couple was quite productive. From 1760 to 1783, Mrs Zumbrink had the privilege of being pregnant or with an infant almost constantly, as witnessed by birth entries on pages 12 (Maria Francellina Frederica), 15 (Christoph Bernard), 19 (Friderich Wilhelm), 25 (Anna Antonella), 30 (Henrich Joseph Anton), 36 (Ignatz Carl), 41 (Maria ... Francisca, born Dec 23, 1775), 46 (Maria Anna Theodora Francisca, born Jul 20, 1778), 53 (Philippina) in this book.
So what happened is the priest took down a wrong name when the Zumbrink daughter got married: her name was Maria ... Theodora, which the priest noted as Maria ... Dorothea.
The right entry is either the one on p. 41 or the one on p. 46. The second one looks good to me, but at 19 years old she would have been quite young to marry. Also, you may wish to check the burial register to see whether those two daughters survived childhood.
J