Rejected Match?

+10 votes
269 views
Hi All,

Moseley-289 and Moseley-1429 were just rejected as a match for a potential merge.

Could others take a look at this? I'm not sure why it was rejected. Or maybe help out with resolving any issues?
WikiTree profile: Robert Moseley
in Genealogy Help by Eric Weddington G2G6 Pilot (525k points)
retagged by Ellen Smith

4 Answers

+7 votes

Looking at them the Birth and Death Locations are different. I do not know how close the birth locations are but the Death Locations have Georgia and Virginia. 

That may be the reason. I notice that the source for Moseley-1429 is an ''Ancestral File'' whereas Moseley-289 seems to have better sources but not one for the death or burial that i can see. 

by Darren Kellett G2G6 Pilot (455k points)
However, the birth dates, death dates, and names are exact. And his wife's name is so close as to be a spelling error. This is what makes me think that this isn't a coincidence, but an issue of proper sourcing.
I've seen rejections occur for data discrepancies like this. I'd reload the merge as an unmerged match for now until you can resolve the location discrepancy, or until the PM relates what other concerns they might have had when rejecting the match.
The PM didn't reject the merge. Someone not associated with the profile rejected
The person who rejected the match was descended from Robert Peter Moseley though he wasn't the PM
+7 votes
You can click on the Changes Tab and find the rejection.  See below.  If you click on Anthony's name, you will end on his profile page.  Click the [send private message] on the right side and email him directly to ask your question.  You might even find a long lost cousin - in contacting him!

https://www.wikitree.com/index.php?title=Special:NetworkFeed&who=Moseley-289
by Chris Hoyt G2G6 Pilot (881k points)
+8 votes

Sources to add

 

Lieutenant Robert Moseley

 in the U.S., Sons of the American Revolution Membership Applications, 1889-1970

VIEWU.S., Sons of the American Revolution Membership Applications, 1889-1970

      Name: Lieutenant Robert Moseley
      Birth Date: Feb 1732
      Birth Place: Henrico, Virginia
      Death Date: 30 Jan 1804
      Death Place: Buckingham, Virginia
      SAR Membership: 42936
      Role: Ancestor
      Application Date: 9 Jan 1930
      Spouse: Magadalene Guerrant
      Children: Peter Guerrant Moseley

      Source Citation

      Volume: 215

      Source Information

      Ancestry.com. U.S., Sons of the American Revolution Membership Applications, 1889-1970 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2011.

       

      by Eddie King G2G6 Pilot (708k points)

       

      Robert Moseley

       in the Virginia, Compiled Marriages, 1740-1850

      No Image
      Text-only collection

          Name: Robert Moseley
          Gender: Male
          Spouse Name: Magdalene Duerrant
          Spouse Gender: Female
          Marriage Date: 23 Sep 1756
          County: Cumberland
          State: Virginia

          Source Information

          Ancestry.com. Virginia, Compiled Marriages, 1740-1850 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 1999.

          Original data: Dodd, Jordan R., et al.. Early American Marriages: Virginia to 1850. Bountiful, UT, USA: Precision Indexing Publishers.

           

          This line I've looked at for the US PRESIDENTS Project - connected to Zachary Taylor. Also coincidentally ancestral to baseball player TY COBB
          •  INDENTURE, made the seventeenth day of October, in the year of Christ one
            thousand seven hundred and seventy-seven, between Robert Moseley, of the
            County of Chesterfield, and Magdalen, his wife, of the one part, and William
            Fleming, of the County of Powhatan, Attorney at Law, of the other part,--
            WITNESSETH: That the said Robert Moseley and Magdalen, his wife, for and in
            consideration of the sum of thirteen hundred pounds, current money, to the
            said Robert in hand paid by the said William Fleming, the receipt whereof is
            hereby acknowledged, they, the said Robert Moseley and Magdalen, his wife,
            have granted, bargained, and sold, aliened and confirmed, and by these
            presents do grant, bargain and sell unto the said William Fleming, his heirs,
            and assigns, a certain tract or parcel of land situated, lying and being on
            both sides of Micheaux's Branch, in the County of Chesterfield, adjoining the
            lands of Thomas Max Randolph, Samuel Landrum, Hawkins Landrum, Smith John
            Trabue and Harris, containing by estimation five hundred and twenty-eight
            acres, be the same more or less, it being the same tract or parcel of land
            whereon the said Robert Moseley now dwelleth two hundred acres, part thereof,
            being the land the said Robert Moseley by indenture bearing the date the sixth
            day of December one thousand seven hundred and sixty, and recorded in the
            County Court of Chesterfield, two hundred and twenty-eight acres, other part
            of the said tract or parcel of land, the said Robert Moseley purchased of
            Jacob Trabue and was conveyed to the said Robert Moseley aby indenture bearing
            date the twenty-second of July one thousand seven hundred and sixty-two, and
            recorded in the County Court of Chesterfield, and one hundred acres, the
            remainder thereof, being the land the said Robert Moseley purchased of Thomas
            Lacy and Nathaniel Lacy, and was conveyed to the said Robert Moseley by
            indenture bearing date the twelfth day of October one thousand seven hundred
            and sixty-three, and is also recorded in the said County Court of
            Chesterfield, and also all lands, houses, trees, woods, profits, commodities,
            hereditaments and appurtenances whatsoever to the said tract or parcel of land
            belonging or in any wise appertaining, and also the reversion and reversions,
            remainder and remainders, rents and services of the said premises and every
            part thereof, and all the estate, right, title interest, claim and demand
            whatsoever of them, the said Robert Moseley and Magdalen, his wife, of in and
            to the said tract or parcel of land and premises hereby bargained and sold,
            and every part thereof-- TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the said tract or parcel of land
            all and singular the said premises above mentioned unto the said William
            Fleming, his heirs and assigns, to the only proper use and behoof of the said
            William Fleming, his heirs and assigns forever, and the said Robert Moseley
            for himself and his heirs the said tract or parcel of land premises and every
            part thereof, against him and his heirs and against all and every person and
            persons whatsoever to the said William Fleming, his heirs and assigns, shall
            and will warrant and forever defend by these presents.
            In Witness whereof the said Robert Moseley and Magdalen, this wife, have
            hereunto set their hands and affixed their seals the day and year first above
            written: Robert Moseley (Seal)/ Magdalen Moseley (Seal) Signed, sealed and
            delivered/ in presence of Thos. Smith, Anna Clarke, Salle Clarke, Hawkins
            Landrum.
            Received of the within named William Fleming the 17th day of October 1777,
            thirteen hundred pounds, the full consideration of the within bargained and
            sold lands and premises:-- Robert Moseley
            Witness: Thomas Smith, Anna Clarke, Salle Clarke
            At a Court held for Chesterfield County November 7, 1777, this deed was
            acknowledged by Robert Moseley, a party thereto, and also by his wife, she
            being privily examined, and was ordered to be recorded. Teste: Ben Watkins, C.
            Robert Moseley came to Buckingham county, Virginia, in 1758 or 1759, built his
            home (burned 1866) on Willow Lake Plantation. Robert Moseley and his wife are
            both buried on the land of "Willow Lake". Stone reads "VA Colonial Troops".
            "Compendium of American Genealogy" says he held the rank of Lieutenant in the
            American Revolution; Deed Book 2:518, 16 Aug 1759 John Bondurant and wife
            Sarah Rachel (Taylor) Moseley Bondurant sell land to Turpin, King William
            Parish Cumberland County; Stutesman; Blankenship, pages 297-317
          •  
          VERY nice work Eddie.
          Wow - good sleuthing!
          You peeps better behave ! I gotta start my cooking for turkey bird day !

          Smooches, hugs and handshakes.
          +4 votes
          The wives' profiles for Lt. Robert Peter Mosely seem to be closely matched and perhaps mergeable.  One Robert Mosely, however, is listed with two different wivves (only one of them is Magdalene Geurrant. If the mix up was attaching Magdalene to the wrong Robert Peter Mosely that might also solve some of the problem.
          by David Hughey G2G Astronaut (1.7m points)
          Yep.  The Lt who died in Georgia was having 10 kids with his 1st wife at the same time as he was marrying Magdalene.  Bad merge or similar.  Needs to lose 2nd wife, and her daughter, and DoB, and DoD, which are all stolen.  Then the resemblance disappears.
          Magdalene's real husband Moseley-1429 is showing as the son of Moseley-1430, d 1781, who has a half-brother of the same name, 241, d 1734.  Could be the half-brother is really a cousin, not a duplicate, in which case he too is a wife-thief, because Sarah Taylor belongs to 241 and 1429 is their son, orphaned young.  Dorman says he chose his guardian at 7, 1738/9.

          There's a confused pedigree in Ancestral File.
          And we seem to have a middle name infestation.

          Related questions

          +3 votes
          1 answer
          +3 votes
          2 answers
          185 views asked Sep 3, 2021 in WikiTree Tech by David Wilson G2G6 Pilot (124k points)
          +11 votes
          2 answers
          332 views asked Jun 23, 2018 in Policy and Style by Jerry Dolman G2G6 Pilot (182k points)
          +4 votes
          1 answer
          186 views asked Jan 30, 2018 in The Tree House by Dorothy Coakley G2G6 Pilot (187k points)
          +10 votes
          1 answer
          186 views asked Jun 5, 2017 in Policy and Style by Rory Bowers G2G6 Mach 1 (10.6k points)
          +6 votes
          1 answer
          111 views asked Jan 27, 2017 in WikiTree Tech by Shirley Dalton G2G6 Pilot (537k points)
          +2 votes
          1 answer
          98 views asked Jan 8, 2017 in WikiTree Tech by T Lacey G2G6 Mach 3 (35.0k points)
          +7 votes
          0 answers
          117 views asked Nov 22, 2016 in WikiTree Tech by Stephanie Stults G2G6 Mach 4 (43.1k points)
          +5 votes
          1 answer

          WikiTree  ~  About  ~  Help Help  ~  Search Person Search  ~  Surname:

          disclaimer - terms - copyright

          ...