Phebe (Hayzlett) Pauley (1795 - abt. 1838)

Ancestors

Wife of Andrew Pauley — married 17 Feb 1812 (to Feb 1838) in Kanawha County, Virginia

Descendants

Died about Feb 1838 at about age 42 in Hancock Co, IN

Problems/Questions Profile manager: Sara Patton [send private message]

Biography

From: BCT29@aol.com Date: Wed, 7 Nov 2001

It is commonly believed and accepted by most PAULEY family researchers that this Andrew Polly is the son of Edward Polly and Mary Agnes Mullins. That however, is unproven in my research or any other that I have seen.

There was also an Andrew Polly in Hancock County, Indiana, in the 1840, 1850 and 1860 Census records, along with Alfred, Edward, Henry and Joseph Polly. In 1860 Andrew, a farmer, was 60 years old, and his wife Mary was 59, both born in Virginia. This is his 2nd wife.

(pauley@iquest.net writes: This Andrew and Phoebe moved into Indiana, Hancock County in 1832. There were several families that came with him. I think they were awarded some and for being a veteran in war of 1812. I have a document that implies this theory. Incidentally, The TV Jane Pauley is descended from Andrew.) ~~ 7 FEB 1812 Kanawha Co, WV Marriage Record 1794-1826 p. 14

Andrew Polly & Phebe Haslet on John Lee list for 1812: no individual date

"Kanawha Co Marriages" by Julia Wintz lists the above marriage along with other Hayzletts/Haslet: It is assumed they are siblings as all live in same neighborhood and marry within same decade.

John Hazelett and Anna Beck, Jun 1 1802

James Blake and Patsey Haslet, Apr 23, 1805;

Samuel Priestly to Isabella Haslet-1810 by Rev. John Lee;

Andrew Polly to Phebe Haslet in 1812 by John Lee;

James Hazlett and Mahala Duncan, Jan 1, 1819;

It appears that Phebe and Andrew were very close to Phebe's sister, Isabella and her husband Samuel Priestly, and lived close together. Samuel PRIESTLY and ANDREW PAULEY appear together in numerous Kanawha Co records.

Kanawha Co Personal Property Tax Records (I've only gotten to 1815) 1812- John Hazlett; James Hazlett; James Blake, Andrew Pauley (No Samuel Priestly who was away at war.) 1813- John Hazelip (no James-was away at war); Richard Hazelip (different district than John), James Blake, Andrew Pauley, (No Samuel Priestly) 1814- John Hazlett; James Hazelett (same district), James Blake, (No Andrew Pauley), Samuel Priestly 1815- John Hazlett; James Hazlett (same district), James Blake, (No Andrew Pauley), Samuel Priestly

Kanawha Co Land Records 1812, April 14: Samuel Priestley "and my wife Izabele" of Kanawha Co sell to Andrew Polley of Kanawha who paid L30 for 50 A in Kanawha Co on Fuquay's Creek. Joseph Thomas Wright sold unto Priestly, his standing not good; Priestly only defends claims from a certain date. Isabel and Samuel both sign names. (Kanawha Co Deed Bk D:28-29.

1813, Oct 9: Samuel Priestly of Kan. Co to Richard Parsons for L30 for 50 acres on Fuquas Creek including forks . Line between Andrew Polley and Samuel Priestly Kanawha Co, WV Deed Bk D: 107-108.

1816, Feb 23: Kanawha Co, VA/WV: Deed: Richard Parsons to ANDREW POLLY for $35 for 35 acres on Fuqua's Creek including low gap between East fork and main fork of Fuqua's. Witnessed by Hannah Beech, SAMUEL PRIESTLY and Henry Pauley (Samuel signs, Henry and Hannah mark) Deed proved by oath of Priestly and Pauley on Oct 15, 1814, by Beech on Feb 23, 1816. Recorded 1822, Nov. 11 (Kanawha Co, WV Deed Bk F:223, 237) (Hannah Hayslett Beach)

1820 Kanawha Co, VA/WV p. 9 Andrew Polly 20001-2001-01 -- 2m &2f under 10 1m &1f -26-45

1822, Sept 4: Kanawha Co, VA/WV: Indenture between John Austin, atty for Thos Stephens (to) ANDREW POWLY for $300 for 390 acres on Little Cole (sic) or South Fork of Cole near Brown and Woods survey at or below Morse? Creek down to below big bend and both sides of river granted to Thos Stephens by patent 25 Oct 1814. witnesses Allen Thomas, Thomas Fowler, Jas. Mac Dowell (Kanawha Co, WV Deed Bk F:114)

1826, Feb 15: Kanawha Co, VA/WV: HENRY & ATHA POLLEY sell land to Joseph Polley on right fork Fuqua Creek, corner to SAMUEL PRIESTLY. Patented to Henry 15 Sept 1819. Witnesses" Joseph Midkiff, Joshua and Andrew Inchminger. (Kanawha Co, WV Deed Bk G:113)

1830 Kanawha Co, VA/WV p.208 Andrew POLLY 202002-130201 2m &1f =under 5 3f =5-10 2m =10-15 2f =15-20 2m &1f =30-40 also: David, Ephraim, Jonathon-20-30, Mohana, Nancy note: Joseph Polly & wife (age 20-30) in Hancock Co, IN in 1830 census p.2.

1830, Sept 23: Samuel Priestly, Andrew Pauley and James J. Straughan witness John Hayzlett's will and Priestly, Pauley and Allen M. Smith appraise his estate on 13 Dec 1830. (Kanawha Co Will Bk 1: 104, 106.)

1830: Sameul Priestly, Andrew and Joseph Pauley appraise Daniel Smith Estate (Kanawha Co. Will Bk1:107)

Between 1830 and 1835 Andrew and Phebe Pauley had moved their family first to Henry Co, IN then to Hancock Co, IN, along with other neighbors and extended family members from the Coal River region of Kanawha Co, VA/WV-- including several Hayzlett nephews, the Barretts, Samples, Lamays, and Hugharts. Andrew Pauley is listed as Justice of the Peace in Hancock Co.

1835: Andrew Pauley of HENRY CO, IN patents 80 acres in Hancock Co, IN on E half of NE 1/4 S19-T16-R8. #16845

1836, Dec 29: ANDREW & “PHEBEY” PAULEY of Hancock Co sell 80 acres to Thomas Johnson for $150. W/2 of SE/4 18-16-8. Phebey signs with +. Edward Pauley, Wm Hatton, and Robt Mc Corkhill witnesses. (Hancock Co, IN Deed Bk E: 426)

1837, March 17: ANDREW PAULEY buys 80 acres from William and Catherine Hatton for $1200. E /2 of NW/4 20-16-8. Witnesses Jordan? Lacy and John AT Crouch (Hancock Co, IN Deed Bk D:178)

1838, Jan 26: ANDREW & PHEBE PAULEY of Hancock Co, IN sell 59 acres for $700 to Wesley Williams. E/2 of NW/4 20-17-8. Phebe signs with a mark +. Same land deeded to Pauleys from Wm Hatton. (Hancock Co, IN Deed Bk E:184)

1838, March 2: ANDREW and Elbina HUGHART of Rush Co sell 40 acres to Westly Williams for $400. NW/4 of SW/4 20-16-8. Witnesses: Meredith Walker & ANDREW PAULEY, JP (Hancock Co, IN Deed Bk E:243)

1838, Mar 28: ANDREW PAULEY (no wife listed) sells 160 acres to Jonathon Dunbar, govt agent, for $73. E/2 of NE/4 19-16-8 and W/2 of NE/4 19-16-8. Witnesses John Hager and Joshua Meek. (Hancock Co, IN Deed Bk #:345)

Because Phebe is listed in Deed Records on Jan 26, 1838 but not on March 8, 1838, it is assumed she died during this period sometime in Feb. Andrew would remarry several times after her death. Death date of 10 Nov 1839 is listed in LDS Ancestral File, no documentation and seems unlikely.

1840 Hancock Co, Jackson Twp, IN p. 189 Andrew Polley - 00200001-0021001 Andrew 50-60 (1780-90) - near Alfred Polley, Edward, Andrew Jr. Joseph, Hezekiah Barrett

1850 Hancock Co, Worth Co, IN p. 192, 4 Oct:

Andrew Pauley -60 VA (ca 1790) farmer $600

Mary -59 VA (Phebe dead)

James Francis -14 IN

1860 Hancock Co, Jackson Twp, Cleaveland PO, IN June 20, 1860. p. 648

Andrew Polley -69 VA farmer $2000/470

Sarah Polley -54 KY

Perry W. Liston -8 IN

George A. Liston -6 IN

near Allen Polly-29 IN w/ son George-6 IN

Find A Grave Memorial# 99858608 Phoebe Pauley Birth Date: 9 Apr 1795 Birth Place: Kanawha County, West Virginia, USA Death Date: 10 Nov 1839 Death Place: Jackson Township, Hancock County, Indiana, USA Cemetery: Simmons Cemetery in Jackson Township, Hancock County, Indiana, USA Spouse: Andrew Pauley Sr

Sources

Julia Wintz, compiler, Kanawha Co Marriages CONT Jan 1 1792 to Dec 31 1869 (McClain PRinting Company. 1975)

Kanawha Co, WV Marriage Records 1794-1826 p. 3

Sara Patton Research

Acknowledgments

Thank you to Sara Patton for creating WikiTree profile Hayzlett-56 through the import of hayzlett-hughart-black-waln-adams.ged on Mar 10, 2013.

Click to the Changes page for the details of edits by Sara and others.