Are these two Spring profiles for the same man?

Question

Is George Spring the same person as Unknown Spring? Familytree has the two men as the same, but with no sources. Is anyone able to find sources that definitely link the two men? I'd love to be able to link the two family groups on Wikitree.

Comments

Searching Scotland's People for William Spring born 1821, using 1818-1830, there was one result:

Surname: SPRING Forename: WILLIAM Parents/ Other Details: WILLIAM SPRING/CHRISTIAN MENNIE Gender: M Date: 07/06/1818 Parish Number: 251/  Ref: 10 445  Parish: Banchory Devenick

So "Unknown" Spring might be William, not George.

Answer 1

Frankly, it is doubtful!

Comments

Hi anon, why do you think it's doubtful?