Hi, Pam,
Welcome to WikiTree!
Unfortunately, here on our world tree "sorting it out" does not include creating a new profile for an individual when one already exists. As you have the profile number, Strong-2156, for Herbert's original profile, that is the one that should have been connected to the father.
I have proposed a merge of the two profiles. If a profile exists for an individual, please connect that profile to your branch rather than create a new one.
Here are a couple of help pages that explain things much better than I can.
Help: Adding Family
Help: Editing Family Relationships
Also, "family history" isn't really an acceptable source and shouldn't be used to prevent the profile from being placed in the unsourced category. In the end, it doesn't benefit anyone and may ultimately cause a lot of extra work for other WikiTreers. If you have no sources for the profiles you are creating than they probably shouldn't be created until you do. If you do have legitimate sources (these are sources that other people can access either online or off and do not include unsourced family trees/genealogies or family lore) then they need to be cited on the profiles.
I know we all get anxious to add our branches to the tree and sometimes mistakes get made. Just slow down a little and you should be fine. Coming to G2G for help is always a good idea when you are in doubt about what to do.