Here's another possible answer that's not directly an answer. It's from a 1903 newspaper, but it concerns the earlier history of Cape May, New Jersey. (I retyped some of the below, so watch for typos)
http://vdls.cmclibrary.org/cgi-bin/capemaycounty?a=d&d=CMH19030131.1.1&e=-------en-20--1--txt-txIN-------
Cape May County History Online -- Chronicling Our Past
Cape May Herald, Cape May City, NJ Saturday, January 31, 1903
Article name "In Local Methodism"
First Church Here a Leading Congregation of Cape May.
"Previous to the introduction of Methodism into this city the morals of the people were distressingly low, and but few religious meetings were held...." (I just liked this sentence, so I had to quote it.)
"In 1837 Rev. Israel Townsend, a devoted man of God, and very highly esteemed and useful local preacher, was invited to come here and preach. He and his brother, Rev. John Townsend, both came and preached at different times in the school house, on Franklin Street...."
"A class met regularly at the house of Jeremiah Church. Prayer meetings were also held there, and at Carson Swain's Lemuel A. Shaw's, Smith Church's, Obadiah Shaw's, William Corgie's and Israel Leaming's, as was found suitable. Socrates Townsend, then a young man 19, was appointed the first class leader."
Although this article does not state who Socrates Townsend was related to, his name emerges not long after the above Reverend Israel Townsend and his brother, the Rev. John Townsend, so I thought there might be a connection there to follow. I also listed the people at the meeting house because there was a Lemuel. It was probably a common name, but in case it influenced the naming of Socrates' son, I thought I'd throw it in there.
Reba