Dodson-570 and Dodson-16 don't look alike to me. They have totally different death dates.
The correct way to do a three profile (or more) merge is to determine first the correct spelling, then the lowest number using that spelling. Then merge the extra profiles into the lowest number with the correct spelling.
If these were the same person, you would merge Dodson-988 into Dodson-16 and Dodson-570 into Dodson-16