Untangling this BLACKWELL family

+5 votes
520 views
George Blackwell, a planter of Edgecombe co. NC, sat down in 1763 and drew up a will that helpfully named his wife and large brood of children.

Daughters Mary, Fanny and Selah, and sons Jesse and George Jr. seem to have been mostly grown and independent, as their father left them a shilling apiece "and no more than [s/he] hath already had". George Jr. was also named an executor of the will along with George Sr.'s wife, Ann.

More children named in the will include sons Hardea, Farabea, William, Abraham, Edmond, and one that seems to be James, as well as daughters named Patience, Amea, and Dorcas. Already we're at 7 named daughters and 8 sons. A sizeable family!

Now a few years later, in April 1767, George Sr.'s will is exhibited as recorded in the Court Minutes of Edgecombe county. A Thorogood Blackwell then apparently questioned the widow Ann's qualifications for being executrix of the will, but the court ruled in Ann's favor. By the way, Thorogood's profile on here has him born in 1760, but it seems unfathomable that a 6 or 7 year old boy went to court.

Now, this Thorogood Blackwell left a will of his own in 1832 Autauga co. AL. In it he directs that "John Booth, Charles Booth and William Booth be equal heirs with my lawful children", etc. etc. For whatever reason, Blackwell genealogists tied themselves into knots trying to come up with theories that these Booths were nephews in some way to Thorogood Blackwell, rather than the seemingly obvious solution that these were out-of-wedlock sons that he was providing for.

Here's where it gets interesting. A male-line descendant of that aforementioned William Booth matched 24/25 Y-DNA markers with a descendant of Abraham Blackwell of Chesterfield District, SC. Putting all this together, it's obvious that not only was Thorogood the biological father of William Booth (and, one presumes, also of Charles and John as well) but that Thorogood and Abraham were therefore closely related in the male line.

Now, both Thorogood and Abraham are listed on Wikitree as sons of George Sr. However, Thorogood is nowhere mentioned in George Sr.'s will. What gives? Why was he not left a shilling? We know from the Court Minutes that he seemed to challenge the widow Ann over the will. Was he an elder son from a previous marriage who'd been cut out of the will? The sheer size of George Sr.'s family would seem to suggest 2 or more wives, although it's not completely impossible that Ann was mother of all of them. In the 1800 census, we find Abraham and Thorogood both living in Chesterfield co. SC, with a Urias Blackwell (age 45+) living nearby. Who is this Urias? Where the hell did he come from? Is this another brother who got cut out of the will?

Also, what IS going on with those names?? Half the names seem like they're from a Quaker background and the other half something any Cavalier family would christen their children. Abraham served in the Revolutionary War, so if he was born a Quaker, he didn't stay one for long.
WikiTree profile: George Blackwell
in Genealogy Help by Jessica Key G2G6 Pilot (319k points)
edited by Jessica Key

2 Answers

+3 votes
Jessica,

I sympathize with you.  My ggg Grandmother, Sarah Scarberry Blackwell Brannon is enigmatic, too.  We aren't really sure of her parentage nor birthplace.  One place she's shown as being born in 1745 in Rome, Floyd Co. GA.  But at that time it would have been Indian Territory.  It didn't become part of GA until after the Trail of Tears.

As to your assessment of George Sr.'s children I agree (including the Booth's.  I wonder if John is John Wilkes Booth who assassinated President Lincoln?).  My only question is whether Urias might be a brother to George Sr., therefore his children's uncle?  

If you run across anything pertinent to my ggg grandmother Scarberry, I will appreciate it.
by
What records do you have for her? I don't mean something unsourced from a Gedcom. I mean a census or a marriage record.
+1 vote
It is my DNA that is matches the person named Booth. Abraham was my 4th Great Grandfather and of course that makes George my 5th Great Grandfather. It is interesting that our line of Blackwell's are members of the R1a Haplogroup while most of the other Blackwell's seem to be from the R1b Haplogroup.
by
Hello, cousin! You and I must be fairly closely related -- Abraham is my 6x great-grandfather.
We are also from the R1a Haplogroup, descended from Davidson Blackwell born c 1809.  May I look at your tree to see where we might intersect?
Hi Becki, I am David Blackwell. This Blackwell line is very difficult to find after the George Blackwell who is my 5th Great Grandfather. It is my brick wall. Records are almost non-existent. A cousin did do a family history, but it it begins with my 4th Great Grandfather Abraham Blackwell who is a son of George. Davidson Blackwell is also another one that I am having a difficult time connecting to the family even though we are DNA matches. If I find anything else out, I will post it here.
Hi Cousin! I am not sure what degree of cousin we are, but I consider all of my cousins no matter what generation. LOL
Is your tree under your name?  There seem to be multiple David Blackwells. Davidson is my 3rd great grandf.  I am also on ancestry under McCallum family tree.  This branch of Blackwells settled in Walker Co Al. beginning with Davidson.  He and Sophia came from Carroll Co Ga.  Where did your branch settle?  Many believe James is his father, but the dna does not seem to support that - although James is a pretty common name.  Some think an Ambrose is involved either as a brother or father but I'm not convinced of that either.  The only other Blackwell I could find in Carroll County at that time was a Jesse Blackwell.  It is all very murky.  I would love to compare our trees to try and find a link
My tree on Ancestry can be found under daveArt50. Let me know I you have trouble finding it.
I did a search for George but did not find your tree.  Is there a way to send me the link?  My direct email is beckmau at gmail
Hello, i just saw this page after doing some more research. Hi, we are within decent cousin range considering George is my 5th Great Grandfather.

Related questions

+2 votes
1 answer
72 views asked Nov 3, 2023 in Genealogy Help by Bob Cole G2G2 (2.4k points)
+1 vote
0 answers
184 views asked Dec 6, 2021 in Genealogy Help by William Dowden G2G6 Mach 1 (11.1k points)
+1 vote
0 answers
+1 vote
0 answers
97 views asked Feb 15, 2020 in Genealogy Help by Melissa Jamison G2G6 Mach 5 (50.2k points)
+2 votes
3 answers
284 views asked Sep 28, 2019 in Genealogy Help by Becki McCallum G2G Rookie (190 points)
+1 vote
1 answer
+3 votes
1 answer
+2 votes
1 answer
113 views asked Jan 30, 2018 in Genealogy Help by Anonymous Anonymous G2G3 (3.6k points)

WikiTree  ~  About  ~  Help Help  ~  Search Person Search  ~  Surname:

disclaimer - terms - copyright

...