There appears to be a significant disconnect in the wikitree profiles for William Simpson-5597 who has a son John married to Christina Campbell and the profile for William Simpson-483 who has a son John married to Hannah Roberts. Reading through the many books written about the ancestors of Hannah Simpson mother of President U. S. Grant this appears to be a long-standing issue with finding definitive primary sources. Currently I think Helen Augusta Simpson's book "Early records of Simpson families in Scotland, North Ireland, and eastern United States : with a history of the family of the compiler, Helen A. Simpson, and including genealogies of allied families of Hout, Stringer, Potts and Dawson." has substantial research and I wonder if Robert's credited her research.