Which one is the correct Daniel Fitzgerald?

Question

I'm looking for Daniel Fitzgerald's parents but am I having an extremely difficult time. I found his death certificate and it said his birth date was January 2nd, 1835 in Ireland. Where in Ireland is a mystery to me. 

 

He married a woman, Ann Carey, who was also born in 1835. Her parents are James Carey(Keary, Carry, Carey, Carew etc) and Bridget Kelly. From what I can tell, they had all of their children in PA. I'm not sure if they were married in Ireland or not. I know Ann Carey's parents died in PA. An Carey can be found in the 1860 census, so she had to have immigrated before then. 

 

Anyway! I don't have anything on Daniel Fitzgerald aside from his birthdate(possibly?) January 2nd, 1835 AND his death date was January 22nd, 1910 in Erie PA.

 

I found a few possibilities-

Daniel Fitzgerald

• Baptized: January 18th, 1835 in Emly, Cashel and Emly, Limerick, Tipperary… Residence Tullow

• Parents: Patrick and Ellen Gubbins

 

Dan Fitzgerald

• Baptized: January 31st, 1835 at Kanturk/Cooleavota/Kanturk and Cooleavota in Cloyne, Cork

• Parents: James

 

Danl Fitzgerald

• Baptized: September 20th, 1835 at Boherbue/Kilmeen in Kerry, Cork, Ireland

• Parents: Jacobi(James) and Honora Daly

 

Daniel Fitzgerald

• Baptized: February 2nd, 1835 in Boherbue, Cork, Ireland

 

• Parents: William Fitzgerald and Julia Moore

 

Daniel Fitzgerald

• Baptized: September 20th, 1835 in Boherbue, Cork, Ireland

 

• Parents: James Fitzgerald and Nora Daly

 

If you find any others let me know. I greatly appreciate it. However we can find out who his parents are! Thank you very much :)

Answer 1

Daniel was born in Limerick, Ireland in 1835, his wife Ann in Ireland in 1835.  They had 4 children, Patrick (1855 -1937) in Penna, Mary E. (1857-1937) in Penna, Nellie (1865)-1952) in Penna, and Bartholomew (Burt) in 1869-1952) in Erie, Pa.   His father Patrick was my GGF2, born in Limerick in 1802 d. 1882 in Limerick. Mother was Catherine Nestor.  Daniel had 2 brothers, David (1830) in Limerick and Thomas (1832) in Askeaton d. 1885. He is my GGF1 and his wife's name was Mary Rafferty.  He emigrated to Canada in 1852, Ohio mid 1860s and Union City, Penna. in late 1860's.