I'm trying to wrap my head around slavery

+22 votes
457 views

Doing genealogy research has exposed me to a lot of information about slavery that I was unaware of  I never knew that slaves were listed in Census schedules without a name. I also didn't know why slaves chose the names they did. It seemed odd to me that someone from Africa would choose a name like Samuel Jones or Benjamin Scurlock instead of an African name from their ancestry.

I read something today about slaves maintaining two names - the one their masters gave them and their real name from Africa. Among other slaves, they were known by their African name. But, I imagine, as time passed and new generations were born into slavery, that tradition was lost. If anyone knows of a good academic study on the naming of slaves, I'd appreciate a pointer.

Recently I was doing research on a family that were slave owners and the owner manumitted a slave family (mother, son, daughter and her children) in his will. So, I thought, one of these days I'm going to research that family and see if I can connect them to the tree.

The greatest frustration I've had in researching African American people is the brick wall you hit in 1860. So, trying to unearth a family that was manumitted in 1804 seemed like an interesting challenge that might actually be doable. They should actually show up in Census records by name.

Today, while doing some research, I came across a book that I immediately ordered from my local library - Slavery in the Family. It's written by Edward Ball, whose family goes back to the founding of the country and kept extensive records on all their slaves (some 400 over the decades.)

Ball researched his family records and tracked down the descendants of his family's slaves and interviewed them.

One thing I found interesting in the promo for the book was that he discovered that slaves tended to NOT take the name of their slave owner but instead chose names of notable people that might give them additional respect. So, the surname of a freed slave might not always indicate who their owner was. I actually thought the opposite.

Reading the names of slaves in a will, alongside cows, pigs, horses, and household goods is disturbing. But, to do the research, you have to overcome the revulsion and look at the evidence with a dispassionate eye.

I admire anyone who does this research. It's so much more difficult than the work I've done uncovering my wife's ancestors.

WikiTree profile: Christopher Smith
in The Tree House by Paul Schmehl G2G6 Pilot (150k points)

6 Answers

+21 votes

Watch Henry Louis Gates’ Finding Your Roots. His guests frequently include Black Americans. Most of their ancestry ends in slavery and goes no further, although there have been noteworthy rare exceptions where people descend from free blacks. He provides lots of examples how their ancestry is determined, and the difficulties of Black American Genealogy. He also does genetic testing and has determined that many Black Americans have European, that is, white ancestry. In some cases these ancestors, who were slave owners, can be identified.

Personally, I find the program very interesting, and intensely moving. His Black American guests know that slavery is a reality in their history, but when their enslaved ancestors are identified by name and no longer forgotten, it is, for some, a very emotional experience.

by George Fulton G2G6 Pilot (645k points)
I watch every time it comes on (if I know about it.) I love that show.
Where I live (California) it is on PBS on Tuesday evenings, mostly reruns, but still worth the time.
It's on auto-record in our house...  Always interesting stories.

There is no way to completely understand the evils of the past.  What is sad is we were so late abolishing the practice that persisted throughout all human history.
Love that show. It has taught me so much about humans.
+21 votes
Nicely said, Paul.

You may be interested in learning more about the Black history project (or even getting involved). It's a very active and interesting project. Find out more here:

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Project:US_Black_Heritage

The full project list can be found under the Find drop down menu.
by Peggy Watkins G2G6 Pilot (845k points)
I've done a few profiles, but I feel grossly unqualified for the work. They recently did a weekend thing through a couple of graveyards. I did one profile and the associated family members. Others did many more.

Hi Paul, I am a team leader and Path guide for the US Black Heritage Project. We appreciate your interest and we would be happy to guide you through our profile standards. They do require very specific things. If you happen to be creating any profiles of persons with Black Heritage, please add the African-American Sticker bracketed by two {{}} .

Joining our project will help get you started on the path: It is extremely easy to join the project. https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Project:US_Black_Heritage

We appreciate your commitment to education and to genealogy and look forward to working with you.

+17 votes
Paul,

This is another one of the reasons why genealogy is so fascinating to me. Instead of seeing history as a broad-brush sweep of EVENTS, it helps in my understanding of the past through a much more human relatable lens.

I also watch Henry Louis Gates' show and participated in his 'challenge' here; and yes, that 1860 barrier is difficult to breach! The human-level reality of the significance of the concepts that created that barrier can be difficult for many of us nowadays to "wrap our heads around". While absolutely NOT wishing to digress into the raw raging realm of our modern sociopolitical world, the idea that we should 'return to something better from the past' appears to be lacking some insight as to what the past was actually like.....

That past not only applied just to Africans and to America. During the research into a branch that participated in the Palatine Migration, I learned that my ancestor had to purchase his family's freedom (also termed as a 'manumission'). He and his family were essentially considered the same as cattle in the pasture. Whichever 'Lord' owned the land, also owned them and that Lord had to be recompensed for his loss before the family could leave the fields and make the trip to America.

Our crazy hobby is full of surprises and I know for myself it has been very educational to go beyond just history and to see His Story.....
by Nick Andreola G2G6 Mach 8 (89.2k points)
Nick, you're absolutely right. The more that I learn, the more I shake my head in amazement and disgust.
+15 votes

Hi Paul, I am a team leader and Path guide for the US Black Heritage Project. We appreciate your interest and we would be happy to guide you through our profile standards. They do require very specific things. If you happen to be creating any profiles of persons with Black Heritage, please add the African-American Sticker bracketed by two {{}} .

Joining our project will help get you started on the path: It is extremely easy to join the project. https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Project:US_Black_Heritage

We appreciate your commitment to education and to genealogy and look forward to working with you.

by Gina Jarvi G2G6 Pilot (147k points)
Gina, thanks for the offer. I'll consider joining, but frankly, I don't feel like I could contribute very much. I know so little, and the few profiles that I've done have been a real struggle to find sources (except for Soup Perkins - Perkins-17380).

I'm working now on the manumitted slaves of Christopher Smith, and I've found two sources so far - his will and a deed of emancipation by Samuel Overton of Hanover County, Virginia, for Marcia Smith Overton and John Willis, children of Betty Kinney. Marcia Smith Overton (b. ca. 1794) and John Willis (b. ca. 1798) were the children of Betty Kinney, a slave of Christopher Smith's.

So, that tells me that Betty had more children than the two mentioned in Smith's will.

BTW, I've added the sticker to every profile (not very many) that I've done.

Is there a discussion list I could monitor so I can learn more?
You can do a whole lot of useful work with USBH without ever going past the 1870 Census. Our Cemeteries team, for example, has a whole lot of profiles to create and there are still lots of folks in the https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Category:US_Black_Heritage_Project%2C_Needs_Profiles_Created category in 1880 and later. So don't be put off; participation in USBH definitely has something for everyone.
When you join (which does not require any specific commitment) you will be put on our email list and you can receive and ask for help. Sources for the enslaved are minimal, but a will, an inventory is huge! Anything with names can lead to more records, and being a collaborative community, what you start, others can jump in. so your contributions are very very helpful and important.
Gina, I've been looking at the project stuff, and I added [[Category:USBH Heritage Exchange, Needs Slaves Identified]] and [[Category:USBH Heritage Exchange, Needs Slave Profiles]] to Christopher Smith's profile. I was not aware of those categories. I also noticed that there is a [[Category:USBH Heritage Exchange, Needs Slave Owner Profile]]. Should I be adding that to Christopher Smith's profile as well?

I discovered last night, while researching the manumitted slaves of Christopher, that free blacks (at least in Louisa County, VA) were required to register with the county every three years. If they didn't register, they could be considered runaways and sold back into slavery. So, while they were technically free, they were under the constant threat of being reenslaved. It's hard for me to grasp such cruelty.

And well-meaning people would purchase slaves so they could free them, without thinking about what the consequences of that so-called freedom might be.

Did the manumitted slave understand that they had to register or they would be re-enslaved? Did they have any money? Any marketable skills with which to earn a living? Were their family members still enslaved? Where would they live?
Paul, Thank you for adding the appropriate categories along with the slave owner category. I see you added a number of slaves to the profile. Good. I would recommend creating a "Slaves of Christopher Smith, Virginia" page to place all of the slave information there. Then link that page back to Smith's profile.

Feel free to add me to the Trusted List of Christopher Smith's profile so I can have it in my watchlist. Also, you may PM me and we can continue this off G2G.
+10 votes
Paul, please don't be intimidated! You have taken the first steps to learning about this section of American genealogy and everyone had to have started somewhere. None of us woke up one day and were able to do this work easily. And we're all still learning!

I hope you'll join the project. There is no set amount of contributions. 1 profile a month or 1000, it all adds up to a lot when we put it together. And our project is full of amazing members who are happy to help you learn more.
by Emma MacBeath G2G Astronaut (1.3m points)
+4 votes
Thanks for your candid descripition of slaves in Wills...  I've read those also and it is difficult to comprehend but I've decided to be more open about this in Profiles ...

I read this g2g of yours first  https://www.wikitree.com/g2g/1501780/learning-about-slavery
thanks for your help and appreciate your openness...
by Beth Schmillen G2G6 Mach 5 (51.7k points)
edited by Beth Schmillen

Related questions

+7 votes
0 answers
+10 votes
1 answer
+26 votes
29 answers
+17 votes
7 answers
641 views asked May 21, 2021 in Genealogy Help by Scott Fulkerson G2G Astronaut (1.5m points)
+1 vote
0 answers
156 views asked Feb 1, 2020 in Policy and Style by Terry Fillow G2G6 Mach 8 (82.4k points)
+6 votes
1 answer

WikiTree  ~  About  ~  Help Help  ~  Search Person Search  ~  Surname:

disclaimer - terms - copyright

...