- Profile
- Images
Date:
[unknown]
[unknown]
Location: [unknown]
Surname/tag: PGM
Location: [unknown]
Surname/tag: PGM
This page has been accessed 1,142 times.
Go to PGM Project Page
Contents |
PGM Profile Review Checklist
Before doing any major work on a profile being managed by PGM:
- Comment on the profile that you plan to enrich and update it.
- Follow this checklist.
BASIC
- Does the profile belong in the Project (migrated between 1621 & 1640)?
- Are there duplicates? If so initiate a merge(s). For further help with merges, see PGM Editing Guidance.
- Are the categories appropriate? Should additional categories be added?
- Categories, templates, and stickers can be added by anyone. They must be in the proper order (see WikiTree help page). Correct order is:
- Categories (see PGM Maintenance Categories for details)
- Research Note Boxes
- Project Boxes
- ==Biography==
- Stickers
DATA SECTION
- New style dates should be used in the Data Field. See Dates, Calendars and Genealogy for help.
- Data Correct? Ensure data fields match what is sourced in the Biography section
- Birth: date/place/parents
- Marriage: date/place/wife(s)
- Death: date/place
- Note: Plymouth Colony 1620-1691;
- Massachusetts Bay Colony 1628-1690;
- Province of Massachusetts Bay 1691-1776.
- Other locations: Location Names by Time Period
- Check the radio buttons and appropriate checkboxes:
- Before, after, estimate, exact? For further guidance on dates, see PGM Editing Guidance.
- No children?
- No more children/siblings?
- No spouse? No more spouses?
BIOGRAPHY SECTION
- If the biography can be enhanced and made more readable with headers, add them.
- Good Sources? See PGM reliable sources
- Are there enough original sources? Add sources from The Great Migration Series by Robert Charles Anderson.
- Are there good derivative or authored sources?
- Spouse(s) sourced? Original sources, names of parents.
- Child(ren) listed? One source citation and an identifying fact. You may choose to use [#] if the birth order is known, or [*] if the order is not known. Any profiles connected as children should also be listed in the biography; it is desirable for every child shown in the biography to have his/her own profile, using at least one reliable source. Any children who migrated with a parent(s) should also have either 1) PGM minor child sticker (if under 21 at migration) or 2) PGM project box, and PGM as a co-manager (if they were adults).
- Good Biography?
- Narrative biographies are preferred. It is acceptable to include bullet points in the narrative.
- Is spelling and punctuation correct, and abbreviations spelled out?
- Does the biography agree with points in the data?
- Are there sentences that point to the information in the data?
- Is there an explanation in the biography for any dates that are only estimated?
- Are the biography and the data in agreement?
- If there is a marriage in the biography, is there an attached profile for the spouse?
- Are the children listed the same ones as the attached profiles?
- 4. Is the migration information included and sourced?
- 5. Are there inline citations throughout the biography? Help with citations is available here.
- Check citation against source material if possible, ensuring data in bio matches info contained in source.
- Make sure source's link in WT is working, and format of citation is correct. Proper formatting for all types of citations (books, periodicals, etc.) can be found here.
- Check sources under "See Also" to make sure format is correct and links are working.
- Remove any online trees and note (or remove) questionable sources.
- 6. If new style dates are used in the data field, double dating should be added to the biography.
- 5. Are there inline citations throughout the biography? Help with citations is available here.
IS THERE DISPUTED INFO?
- Are there Disputes? Add a Research Note Box AND add detailed information about the dispute in the Research Notes section, under a level three heading ===Disputed XYZ===. Then the profile should be project-protected. Make a comment on the profile such as: "Disputed section added, ready for Leader to PPP."
IMAGES
- Are all images relevant to the profile?
- Are they in the public domain? Make sure there is a source attached AND a statement of why it can be used (i.e Creative Commons... public domain...).
- If a wallpaper is used, is it subtle? Does it distract from the text? These are usually not recommended on PGM profiles.
- If the images are within the biography section, are they a reasonable size and do they appear properly placed (e.g., left or right justified, or centered) These are usually not recommended on PGM profiles.
Collaboration
- Login to request to the join the Trusted List so that you can edit and add images.
- Private Messages: Contact the Profile Managers privately: Bobbie Hall and S Willson. (Best when privacy is an issue.)
- Public Comments: Login to post. (Best for messages specifically directed to those editing this profile. Limit 20 per day.)
- Public Q&A: These will appear above and in the Genealogist-to-Genealogist (G2G) Forum. (Best for anything directed to the wider genealogy community.)
Comments: 1
Leave a message for others who see this profile.
There are no comments yet.
Login to post a comment.