Who did John Barrickman (Barrickman-1) marry? [closed]

Question

I have been updating the profile of Barbara Franks (Franks-115) and was about to add her spouse, John Barrickman, only to discover that he (Barrickman-1) was already in the tree, but had a different spouse, Barbara Pickenpaugh (Pickenpaugh-19). This is a genealogical disagreement that has been around a while. I have detailed what I have learned of it in the research notes on Franks-115. At this point I need help. Although I am presently convinced that Franks-115 is the correct spouse for Barrickman-1, I don't wish to proceed without some guidance from those more experienced than I.

Answer 1

West Virginia, Deaths Index, 1853-1973

Name:	Barbara Barrickman
Birth Date:	1781
Birth Place:	Pennsylvania
Death Date:	26 Oct 1857
Death Place:	Monongalia County, West Virginia
Death Age:	76
Gender:	Female
Father Name:	James Franks
Mother Name:	Barbara Franks
FHL Film Number:	464965
Wills and Probates:	Barbara Barrickman - 1857

Source Information:

Ancestry.com. West Virginia, Deaths Index, 1853-1973 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2011.

Original Data:

"West Virginia Deaths, 1853–1970." Index. FamilySearch, Salt Lake City, Utah. From originals housed in county courthouses throughout West Virginia. "Death Records."

Comments

Thanks, but I already have that source on Franks-115 profile, but it does not resolve the conflict, those who hold with Peckinpaugh claim that is a different Barbera Barrickman...

---

okay, but checking census records, 1850

there are only 2 John Barrickman in Monongalia, Virginia

John and his son John whose wife was Elizabeth

---

thanks for the gold star