Caroline M Beebe (1867 - 1931)

Born Apr 1867 in Salem, Washington, New York, United States

Ancestors

Died 1931 at about age 63 in Salem, Washington, New York, United States

Problems/Questions Profile manager: Randy Beebe [send private message]

Biography

Carie was born in 1867. She is the daughter of George Beebe and Maria Montgomery.

Genealogical Records

Census Records

• Primary Source, United States Census, 1880, ^[1] : Data summary: In the 1880 census, George Beebe, age (54) was the head of a Salem, Washington, New York household. Members of the household include:

1. ) 1880 Census, Image 39 of 55: George Beebe, Self, Male, 54, New York, United States
2. ) Moria Beebe, Wife, Female, 48, New York, United States
   1. ) Ollover W Beebe, Son Male, 19, New York, United States
   2. ) Carie M Beebe, Daughter, Female, 13, New York, United States
   3. ) Annie C Beebe, Daughter, Female, 9, New York, United States

Death Records

• Primary Source, (burial); Tertiary Source (biography), Find A Grave Index ^[2] Data Summary:

1. ) Find A Grave: Memorial #75792771: Caroline (Beebe) Capen was born Apr 1867 at Salem, Washington County, New York, USA, and she died 1931 (aged 63–64) at Schenectady County, New York, USA
2. ) BURIAL. Caroline (Beebe) Capen was buried in the Evergreen Cemetery at Salem, Washington County, New York, USA
   1. ) Find a Grave Notes: " "
   2. ) Inscription, "{No Tombstone Photo}"

Biographic and Genealogical References

{IMPORTANT EDITORIAL NOTE: the following extract from the Clarence Beebe has significant genealogical information error. The genealogy incorrectly assigns Carrie Beebe of this profile as a granddaughter of Roderick Beebe, son of Asa Beebe rather than as a granddaughter of Roderick Beebe, son of Reuben. The research notes provide an analysis of the origin of the erroneous genealogical information for this family. }

• Secondary Source, Clarence Beebe in his book Monograph of the Descent of the Family of Beebe ^[3] cites Carrie Beebe in profile (1108). Data summary;

1. ) Monograph, etc., Page 50. ASA Beebe (355), son of Asa Beebe (167), was born in Colchester, Conn. on 2 May 1764. Married Sarah Day; moved to Vermont, and thence to Munroe County, N.Y. Children: Asa (561), Minoris (562), Orin (563), Roderick (564), Salmon (565), Clarissa (566), Sarah (567), and Lydia (568).
2. ) Monograph, etc., Page 67. RODERICK Beebe (564), son of Asa Beebe II (355), was born in 1790. Children: Oliver C. (868), George (869), Sarah (870), Deborah (871), Elizabeth (872), and William (873). {This asserted relationship is incorrect, George Beebe (869) and Roderick Beebe II (564), son of Asa are third cousins. See research notes for analysis.}
3. ) Monograph, etc., Page 91. George Beebe (869), son of Roderick Beebe II (564). Children: George (1106), Oliver (1107), Carrie (1108), and Anna (1109) {This asserted father-son relationship is incorrect, George Beebe (869) is the son of Roderick Beebe, son of Reuben, rather than Roderick Beebe II (564), son of Asa as asserted in Monograph, etc. See research notes for analysis.}
4. ) Monograph, etc., Page 109: CARRIE Beebe (1108), daughter of George Beebe (869)

Research Notes

1. ) Oliver William (1107), George (1106), Carrie (1108), and Anna (1109) were the grandchildren of Roderick Beebe, son of Reuben, NOT Roderick Beebe II (564), son of Asa. The basis for this argument is as follows:
   1. ) Roderick Beebe II (564), son of Asa, was born 20 Aug 1807 at Winhall, Bennington County, Vermont. He lived in Winhall, Vermont until some time between 1810 and 1830, when he removed with his father to Greece, Monroe County, New York. Next, Roderick Beebe and his cousin Huron Beebe became early pioneers at Chagrin Falls, Ohio in 1836 where he married Paulina Warren, and had four children, Attillia, Orrin, Julia, and George Vernon Beebe. He remained in the Cleveland, Ohio until sometime prior to 1860 when he separated from his wife and family and moved to Indianapolis. All of these facts are supported by primary source documentation cited in his Wikitree profile. There is no evidence Roderick Beebe, son of Asa, ever set foot in Salem, Washington County, New York.
   2. ) The 1855 Salem, Washington County, NY Census documents William and Elizabeth to be living in the household of their father Roderick Beebe in 1855, and that the date of birth of their father was circa 1777. Therefore, Roderick, the father of William and Elizabeth was about 30 years older than Roderick, son of Asa.
   3. ) Sarah (Beebe) Almy (870) was born in 1817; Roderick Beebe II (564), son of Asa was only 10 years old at the time of her birth, hence it was impossible for him to be her father. Furthermore each of her siblings had been born before Roderick, son of Asa, reached the age of 21, again facts which are confirmed with primary source documentation.
   4. ) There are primary source documents confirming that each of the children of Roderick; Oliver C. (868), George (869), Sarah (870), Deborah (871), Elizabeth (872), and William (873), were born and/or lived in Salem, Washington County, New York for a significant period of their lives.
   5. ) Finally, Oliver C. (868), George (869), Sarah (870), Deborah (871), and Elizabeth (872) are named as children and heirs of Roderick Beebe, son of Reuben in his Salem, Washington, New York, last will and testament.

Research Notes

1. ) The following definitions and syntax conventions apply to the preceding text of this profile:
   1. ) A Primary Source contains data that was recorded by the person in the profile; or by someone known to or with first hand knowledge of that person, during the person's lifetime, death or within two generations thereafter.
   2. ) A Secondary Source is a genealogical reference created as the result of a extensive study of available source material and it provides some evidence of the source documentation used to generate the text data.
   3. ) A Tertiary Source is a genealogical data source which is a collection of genealogical information that does not cite Primary or Secondary information sources, and the data may be factual or hearsay.
   4. ) Braces {Editorial Note Example} are used to insert editorial comments; that is to say, information or clarification that is not contained in the original, cited source material.

Sources

1. ↑ "United States Census, 1880," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:MZN8-87X : 21 August 2017), George Beebe, 1880; citing enumeration district ED 153, sheet 427A, NARA microfilm publication T9 (Washington D.C.: National Archives and Records Administration, n.d), roll 0942; FHL microfilm 1,254,942. George Beebe in the 1880 US census
2. ↑ Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 13 January 2020), memorial page for Caroline Beebe Capen (Apr 1867–1931), Find A Grave Memorial no. 75792771, citing Evergreen Cemetery, Salem, Washington County, New York, USA ; Maintained by clsk22 (contributor 47220038) .
3. ↑ Beebe, Clarence, Monograph of the Descent of the Family of Beebe, from the earliest known immigrant--John, of Broughton, England, 1650, compiled and edited by Clarence Beebe, 150 Nassau Street, New York,1904; Public Domain. Profile (1108), page 109. Clarence Beebe Genealogy online -Title Page

Other Sources

• "United States Census, 1880," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:MZN8-87J : 21 August 2017), Carie M Beebe in entry for George Beebe, 1880; citing enumeration district ED 153, sheet 427A, NARA microfilm publication T9 (Washington D.C.: National Archives and Records Administration, n.d), roll 0942; FHL microfilm 1,254,942.